The 2015 onion study by Fayos and colleagues found that, under one of two culture protocols, doubled haploid onion plants grown in an Eco2Box vessel showed 4.2% hyperhydricity against about 35% in two other containers, and 70.8% became acclimatised plants. Under the other protocol there was no significant hyperhydricity difference. Each group held 16 to 35 embryos.
What did the Fayos 2015 onion study test?
Fayos et al. 2015 is a study on producing doubled haploid onion plants, published in Frontiers in Plant Science 6:384. The container comparison is one experiment inside it. Embryos of one onion population were grown into plants in three container types, after two different induction protocols, and the authors counted hyperhydric plants and acclimatised plants.
The three containers were glass tubes with plastic plugs, a culture box from another manufacturer, and what the paper calls “polypropylene boxes with an aeration filter (Eco2box-green filter-Model 80MM H […])”. The full text is open access: Fayos et al. 2015, doi 10.3389/fpls.2015.00384. The authors declare no commercial or financial relationships.
Hyperhydricity means glassy, watery plants. Both outcomes are counted per 100 embryos placed in the container, and compared with a chi-square test at P below 0.05.
What are the exact figures in the Fayos 2015 study?
Under protocol B, 1 of 24 embryos in the Eco2Box vessel gave a hyperhydric plant (4.2%) and 17 of 24 gave an acclimatised plant (70.8%). In glass tubes that was 9 of 26 (34.6%) and 6 of 26 (23.1%). In the other box it was 8 of 23 (34.8%) and 12 of 23 (52.2%).
| Protocol | Container | Embryos | Hyperhydric plants | Acclimatised plants |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A (one step) | Glass tube, plastic plug | 35 | 6 (17.1%) | 7 (20.0%) |
| A | Eco2Box, green filter | 28 | 3 (10.7%) | 7 (25.0%) |
| A | Box from another manufacturer | 16 | 3 (18.8%) | 6 (37.5%) |
| B (two steps) | Glass tube, plastic plug | 26 | 9 (34.6%) | 6 (23.1%) |
| B | Eco2Box, green filter | 24 | 1 (4.2%) | 17 (70.8%) |
| B | Box from another manufacturer | 23 | 8 (34.8%) | 12 (52.2%) |
Source: Table 3 of the paper, second experiment, checked against the full text on 20 November 2026. Under protocol B the paper marks the Eco2Box hyperhydricity figure as significantly different from the other two, and all three acclimatisation figures as different from each other.
What did the study not find?
Under protocol A the study found no significant difference in hyperhydricity between the three containers, and the box from another manufacturer gave the most acclimatised plants (37.5%, against 25.0% for the Eco2Box vessel and 20.0% for glass tubes). The effect in favour of the Eco2Box vessel appears under protocol B only.
The authors report “an interaction between container and protocol”. In plain words: the container mattered under one protocol and not under the other. The paper adds that protocol B gave “higher percentages of hyperhydricity and acclimated plants than protocol A, except when Eco2 boxes were used”.
Which caveats belong to the Fayos 2015 figures?
Six caveats belong to the figures: small groups, one species and population, unequal plant density, an unconfirmed filter grade, whole containers compared and not one factor, and no repeat of the experiment. The 70.8% rests on 17 plants.
- Small groups. 16 to 35 embryos per group, about 24 under protocol B. In a group of 24, one plant more or less moves a percentage by about 4 points.
- One species, one population. All embryos in this experiment came from one onion population (OH-1), which the paper describes as highly responsive. It is one lab and one season, 2013.
- Plant density differed. The paper states 4 to 6 plants per Eco2Box vessel against 2 to 3 per box of the other type.
- Filter grade unconfirmed. The paper says “green filter”. Which Eco2Box grade that was at the time is not confirmed, so no grade is attached to these results.
- Whole containers compared. Shape, volume, closure and density all differ between the three. The authors write that the result “could be due to the presence of an aeration filter in the lid”: a possible reason, not a measured one. The paper reports no gas exchange measurement.
- No repeat. The paper reports one run of this comparison.
How should a lab use this study?
Use the Fayos 2015 study as a reason to test, not as a prediction. It shows that in one onion experiment a filtered Eco2Box vessel went together with fewer glassy plants and more acclimatised plants under one protocol. It does not show what happens with your crop, your medium or your protocol.
Published work says more generally that gas exchange should be matched to the species, the stage and the medium, not maximised. The guide on choosing a filter grade gives starting points per stage. The paper names a model 80 mm high and does not say which set that was; one current set of that height is the OV80.
How sure is this reading?
The figures are certain: they are copied from Table 3 of the paper and the counts match the percentages. The explanation is not: the paper offers the filter as a possible cause. ECO2 nv did not run the study, and no second independent comparison of the Eco2Box vessel has been published as far as ECO2 knows.
Frequently asked questions
Did the Fayos 2015 study prove that the Eco2Box reduces hyperhydricity?
No. It measured 4.2% hyperhydricity in the Eco2Box vessel against about 35% in two other containers under one protocol, with about 24 embryos per group, and no significant difference under the other protocol. That is one result on one species, not proof for other crops.
How many plants was the 70.8% based on?
On 17 acclimatised plants from 24 embryos grown in the Eco2Box vessel under protocol B. The glass tube group gave 6 from 26 embryos and the box from another manufacturer 12 from 23.
Which Eco2Box filter grade did the study use?
The paper names an Eco2Box with a green filter, model 80 mm high. In the current Eco2Box range green is grade XXL+, but which grade the green filter was in 2013 is not confirmed, so ECO2 attaches no grade to the result.
Was the study paid for by ECO2?
No. The paper names public funding from the Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness and the Aragon Government. Its authors, at two research institutes in Zaragoza, Spain, declare no commercial or financial relationships. ECO2 nv, the maker of the Eco2Box, is not named as a funder.
Request a sample set or ask a question
The way to know what a filtered vessel does for your crop is to run it next to your current one. A sample set of filtered Eco2Box containers is available on request: request a sample set, or ask a question and name your species and stage.
Related guides: Published studies that used Eco2Box vessels, How to prevent hyperhydricity: medium and vessel.
Sources
- Fayos O, Vallés MP, Garcés-Claver A, Mallor C, Castillo AM. 2015. Doubled haploid production from Spanish onion (Allium cepa L.) germplasm: embryogenesis induction, plant regeneration and chromosome doubling. Frontiers in Plant Science 6:384. doi 10.3389/fpls.2015.00384. Open access, CC BY. Read on 20 November 2026.