TL;DR Ex vitro survival by vessel type has been measured in single-crop studies only. In the three we could open, on onion, pepper and a medicinal herb, a more ventilated vessel or closure came with more surviving plants in at least one condition, and in one study a different container did best under a second protocol. The studies use different vessels, group sizes and endpoints, so their figures cannot be added up. We found no review that pools them.
Ex vitro survival is the share of plants that live through the move from the culture vessel to substrate. This page lists the studies we opened, each with its crop, vessels, group size and result, and stops there.
Does the vessel change ex vitro survival?
In each of the three studies listed here, the number of plants that survived transfer differed by vessel or closure, but not always in the same direction or under every protocol. Each result belongs to one species and one set-up. We found no published comparison across crops, and this page does not make one.
Which studies report ex vitro survival by vessel or closure?
Three studies that we read in full report survival or acclimatisation by vessel or closure, and a fourth compared vessels without giving a figure in its abstract. The table gives each one with its own denominator.
| Study | Crop | Vessels or closures compared | Group size | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fayos et al. 2015 | Onion, doubled haploids | Glass tube; Eco2Box vessel with green filter; culture box from another manufacturer | 16 to 35 embryos per arm | Acclimatised plants per 100 embryos. Protocol B: 23.1%, 70.8%, 52.2%. Protocol A: 20.0%, 25.0%, 37.5% |
| Mohamed and Alsadon 2011 | Pepper, cv. Anaheim | 250 ml jars, polypropylene lid with or without a microporous membrane | Not stated for survival | Survival after 4 weeks: 75 to 86% with membrane, 44 to 61% without (the paper’s text; its table shows 49 to 61%) |
| Chen et al. 2006 | Scrophularia yoshimurae, a medicinal herb | 500 ml glass flasks capped with aluminium foil or 2, 3 or 4 layers of paper | 18 plantlets per treatment | Best paper closure: 77.8% at 4 weeks, 66.7% at 8 weeks. Foil: 27.8%, then under 7% |
| Paynter 2022 | Strawberry | Vented and non-vented vessels | Not in the abstract | No survival figure in the abstract; full text not read |
Onion: three containers, two protocols
In onion, the container that gave the most acclimatised plants depended on the protocol. Fayos et al. 2015 regenerated doubled haploid plants from embryos in three containers and counted acclimatised plants per 100 embryos, which is a wider measure than survival of transferred plants.
| Container | Protocol A: embryos, acclimatised | Protocol B: embryos, acclimatised |
|---|---|---|
| Glass tube with plastic plug | 35, 20.0% | 26, 23.1% |
| Eco2Box vessel, green filter | 28, 25.0% | 24, 70.8% |
| Other culture box | 16, 37.5% | 23, 52.2% |
Under protocol B, hyperhydricity was 4.2% in the Eco2Box vessel against about 35% in the two others; under A it did not differ significantly. Plant density differed: 4 to 6 plants per Eco2Box vessel against 2 to 3 per box of the other type. Which Eco2Box filter grade the green filter was is not confirmed. The comparison sat inside a breeding study and compared whole containers, not one factor.
Pepper: a lid with or without a membrane
In pepper, plantlets from jars with a membrane lid survived acclimatisation more often than plantlets from jars with a plain lid. Mohamed and Alsadon 2011 grew cultures in 250 ml jars closed with a polypropylene lid with or without a microporous membrane.
- Survival after 4 weeks of acclimatisation: 75 to 86% with the membrane, 44 to 61% without, across four growth regulator treatments. That lower range is from the paper’s text; its table 2 shows 49 to 61%.
- The growth regulators had no significant effect on survival.
- Ventilated plantlets had more dry mass and fewer stomata per leaf area.
- The paper does not state how many plantlets were transferred per treatment.
A medicinal herb: foil against paper closures
In Scrophularia yoshimurae, flasks closed with paper gave more survivors than flasks closed with aluminium foil. Chen et al. 2006 transferred six rooted plantlets in three replicates per treatment, 18 in all.
- Three layers of paper: 77.8% alive after 4 weeks in a humid box, 66.7% after 4 more weeks at room conditions.
- Aluminium foil: 27.8% after 4 weeks, under 7% after 8.
- Four layers of paper did worst of the paper closures and still gave more survivors than foil.
With 18 plantlets per treatment, one plant is 5.6 percentage points.
Why can these ex vitro survival figures not be pooled?
The figures cannot be pooled because the studies do not measure the same thing in the same way. Five differences stand out:
- Endpoint: acclimatised plants per embryo in onion, survival of transferred plantlets in the other two.
- Moment: 4 weeks in pepper, 4 and 8 weeks in the herb.
- Vessels: a filter vessel, a membrane lid, layers of paper. None of the three reports a gas exchange rate for the closed vessel.
- Group size: 16 to 35 embryos, 18 plantlets, or not stated.
- Other variables moved with the vessel, such as plant density in the onion study.
What is missing from the literature?
What is missing is a study that compares named closures with a measured gas exchange rate, on more than one crop, with survival counted the same way. We also found no published work that says how long before transfer the vessel conditions should change.
The direction is not universal either. Published work on some species and stages found better results under sealed or low-exchange conditions, which is why gas exchange is matched to the crop and not maximised. For crops such as blueberry and raspberry we found no vessel study at all.
How do you get a figure for your own crop?
The only survival figure that counts for your lab is the one from your own crop, so run the comparison yourself. Keep medium, shelf and plants per vessel equal, change the vessel or the filter grade only, and count survivors at a fixed number of weeks after transfer. The guide on choosing a filter grade gives the Eco2Box grade per stage.
Frequently asked questions
Is there proof that ventilated vessels improve survival after transfer?
There is evidence per crop, not general proof. Three studies on onion, pepper and a medicinal herb found more survivors from a more ventilated vessel in at least one condition. Only the onion study used an Eco2Box vessel, and there another container did best under a second protocol.
What survival did the Eco2Box vessel reach in the onion study?
Under protocol B, 70.8% of 24 embryos gave an acclimatised plant from the Eco2Box vessel, against 23.1% and 52.2% from the two other containers. Under protocol A it was 25.0% of 28, and another container reached 37.5%. Plant density differed between containers.
Why is there no average across studies here?
An average would mix different endpoints, crops, group sizes and closures. Eco2Box guides give each study with its own denominator and leave the comparison to a trial on your own plants.
Did these studies test Eco2Box filter grades?
No. One study used an Eco2Box vessel with a green filter in its methods, and the grade is not confirmed. None compared the four Eco2Box grades, L, XL, XXL and XXL+, with each other.
Which Eco2Box grade is meant for the stage before transfer?
The ECO2 filter guide suggests XXL+ for acclimatisation and hardening off. That is ECO2’s own guidance, not a result of the studies on this page, and more ventilation raises the risk that the medium dries out.
Request a sample set or ask a question
To add your own crop to this list, compare a filtered Eco2Box set with your current vessel through transfer. A sample set, for example of the OV80 with filter cover, is available on request: request a sample set. If you know a study that belongs on this page, tell us. The sets are listed on the product range page.
Related guides: Hardening of tissue culture plants: the vessel’s part, The 2015 onion study, read carefully (Fayos et al.).
Sources: Fayos et al. 2015, Frontiers in Plant Science 6, 384, doi 10.3389/fpls.2015.00384. Mohamed and Alsadon 2011, Biologia Plantarum 55, pages 370 to 374, doi 10.1007/s10535-011-0057-z. Chen, Hsia, Agrawal and Tsay 2006, Botanical Studies 47, pages 259 to 266. Paynter 2022, doi 10.1007/s11627-022-10269-6 (abstract). Checked on 20 November 2026.