TL;DR A fair culture vessel trial changes one thing: the vessel. Take plant material from one batch, put the same number of plants in every vessel, stand test and current vessels on the same shelf, and let the trial run a full culture cycle. Score condensation, contamination, plant quality, medium and breakage on one sheet, then judge again after planting out, because that is where a difference in survival shows.
A culture vessel trial often ends without an answer: the plants look the same in both vessels, or condensation shows in every vessel on the shelf. This guide gives the set-up, the duration, the five scores and a score sheet you can print.
What makes a culture vessel trial fair?
A culture vessel trial is fair when the vessel is the only thing that differs between the groups. The plant batch, the medium, the person, the day, the number of plants per vessel and the shelf are the same for the test vessels and for the vessels you use now. Everything you do not hold equal becomes a second explanation for any difference.
| Keep the same | How |
|---|---|
| Plant material | One batch from one mother stock, divided at random over the groups |
| Medium | One preparation, poured on the same day |
| Plants per vessel | The same number in every vessel of similar size; note it when sizes differ |
| Person and day | One person fills and transfers all groups in one session |
| Place | One shelf, with test and current vessels mixed over the positions |
| The one change | The vessel, or the filter grade (how much air the filter lets through) |
No published protocol for comparing vessels in a production lab was found for this guide. Research papers compare vessels inside single-crop studies, each with its own method.
Step 1: Decide what the vessel trial has to answer
Write down one question before the samples arrive, together with the result that would make you switch. “Fewer glassy shoots in multiplication” or “more plants alive after planting out” can be scored. “See how they do” cannot. Agree the question with the person who decides on the order.
Then change one thing. A new vessel and a new medium, room or protocol in the same trial give a result you cannot assign to any of them. To compare filter grades as well, treat each grade as its own group next to your current vessel.
Step 2: Use one batch, one shelf and the same plant count
Take all plant material from one batch, divide it at random over the groups, and put the same number of plants in each vessel. Stand the test vessels and your current vessels on the same shelf, mixed over the positions. Shelf position matters because temperature swings from the lighting change the real gas exchange in a vessel.
A published comparison shows why the plant count deserves attention. Fayos et al. 2015 compared three containers on doubled haploid onion. The Eco2Box vessels held 4 to 6 plants each, against 2 to 3 per culture box from another manufacturer. Density therefore differed between the groups together with the container. In your own trial you can keep the count equal. Use the same number of vessels in every group, and enough that one lost vessel does not decide the outcome.
Step 3: How long should a vessel trial run?
Run a vessel trial for at least one full culture cycle of the crop, as long as your normal cycle, and carry on to planting out when survival is part of the question. Slow growers need more weeks before a difference shows.
The end of the cycle matters for a second reason. More ventilation means less condensation, and a higher risk of the medium drying out. The medium is scored at the end of the cycle, so a trial that stops early cannot score it. Fix three scoring days at the start: one early look, the end of the cycle, and a day after planting out.
Step 4: What to measure in a vessel trial, on one score sheet
Score five things per group, on the same days for every group: condensation, contamination, plant quality, how the medium holds up, and breakage. Count vessels and plants, take a photo of each group on every scoring day, and print the sheet below once per scoring day.
| Score | How to record it | Current vessel | Test vessel 1 | Test vessel 2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Trial | Crop, stage, batch, start date, scoring date, name | |||
| Vessel and filter grade | Article and grade per group | |||
| Vessels started | Number | |||
| Plants per vessel | Number | |||
| Condensation | Vessels with drops on the wall or the lid, out of vessels started | |||
| Contamination | Vessels lost, out of vessels started; note where the growth began | |||
| Plant quality | Glassy shoots (hyperhydricity), number of shoots, leaf colour, roots | |||
| Medium | Vessels with dried or cracked medium at the end of the cycle | |||
| Breakage and handling | Vessels or lids cracked; lids that did not close | |||
| After planting out | Plants alive, out of plants planted, on a fixed day | |||
| Decision | Answer to the question from step 1 |
Read the contamination row with care. Contamination has three routes into a vessel: the closure, handling, and the plant material itself. A vessel trial tests the first. Lost vessels in every group say little about the vessel.
Step 5: Judge the vessel trial after planting out
Take the last score outside the vessel: plants alive out of plants planted, per group, on a fixed day after planting out. How plants look inside the vessel does not settle the question. In a raspberry study by Lebedev et al., shoot height at the multiplication stage did not correlate with plant growth during acclimatisation (acclimation in US usage).
Fayos et al. 2015 scored both stages on doubled haploid onion. Under their protocol B, with 23 to 26 embryos per group, hyperhydricity was 4.2% in the vessel with the Eco2Box green filter, against about 35% in a glass tube and about 35% in the culture box from another manufacturer. Of the embryos, 70.8% became acclimatised plants from the Eco2Box vessel, against 23.1% from the glass tube and 52.2% from the other box.
The limits belong to those figures. Under protocol A, with 16 to 35 embryos per group, hyperhydricity did not differ significantly between the containers, and the other box gave the most acclimatised plants (37.5%). Plant density differed: 4 to 6 plants per Eco2Box vessel against 2 to 3 per box of the other type. Which Eco2Box grade the green filter was is not confirmed. It is one study on one species, and the result changed with the protocol. That is the reason to run the trial on your own crop with your own protocol.
Which mistakes make a vessel trial inconclusive?
- Judging a slow crop in the first weeks.
- Filling test and current vessels from different batches or on different days.
- Putting more plants in one vessel type than in the other.
- Changing the medium or the protocol during the trial.
- Using so few vessels that one lost vessel decides.
- Leaving out your current vessel as the control on the same shelf.
Condensation in both the test and the control vessels makes a trial hard to read: it cannot separate the vessels on that one score. Keep scoring the other four points. If the packaging of a sample parcel arrives damaged, tell us before you start.
What do you need for a culture vessel trial?
You need your current vessel as the control, the test vessels, plant material from one batch, the score sheet and a camera. For a trial with Eco2Box containers, ECO2 nv supplies a sample set on request, chosen from your crop, the stage and the container you use now.
Eco2Box sets come in four filter grades with rising gas exchange: L (white), XL (yellow), XXL (red) and XXL+ (green). XXL is the standard for most propagation. Choosing a filter grade gives a starting grade per stage. One of the bestsellers is the round O118/80 of 565 ml. The vessels are clear, so you can score condensation and plant quality without opening them.
Ask which version your samples are before you sterilise anything. Untreated polypropylene vessels and covers are autoclaved at 121 °C before first use, and we recommend at most 5 uses. Gamma irradiated articles are supplied sterile; autoclaving them is not recommended (at most 2 to 3 cycles, and the plastic turns brittle and yellowish).
Frequently asked questions
How long should I test a new culture vessel?
Test a new culture vessel for at least one full culture cycle of your crop, and until after planting out when survival matters. Slow growers need more weeks before a difference shows. Repeat the cycle when the first one gives a hint and no clear answer.
How many vessels do I need for a vessel trial?
No published minimum exists for a vessel trial in a production lab. Use the same number of vessels in every group, and enough that one vessel lost to contamination does not change the outcome. Write the number down before you start.
Can I test a new vessel and a new medium at the same time?
No. A trial that changes the vessel and the medium together gives a result you cannot assign to either. Change only the vessel or the filter grade, and test the medium in a separate trial.
What if condensation shows in both the test and the control vessels?
Then the trial cannot separate the vessels on condensation. Note the shelf position and the distance to the lamp for every vessel, keep scoring contamination, plant quality, medium and breakage, and compare again at the end of the cycle. Conditions outside the vessel, such as room temperature and lighting, also change what happens inside it.
Can I get Eco2Box samples to run a trial?
Yes. A sample set of Eco2Box containers with a filter lid is available on request. Tell ECO2 nv your crop, the stage, the container you use now and how many plants go in one container. The container size and the filter grades to compare are chosen from that.
Request a sample set for your vessel trial
Run this trial on your own plants, next to the vessels you use now. Request a sample set and tell us your crop, the stage and your current container. If you first want to talk through the set-up of your trial, ask us a question.
Related guides: Ex vitro survival by vessel type: what studies say, Green or white filter: gas exchange (Kv) per Eco2Box grade.
Sources: Fayos O, et al. 2015, Frontiers in Plant Science 6:384, doi 10.3389/fpls.2015.00384. Lebedev V, et al. 2018, Plants 8(1):3, doi 10.3390/plants8010003. Eco2Box product facts from the ECO2 filter guide and product specifications. Checked on 20 November 2026.